Gentle Tips to Help Babies Self-Soothe and Replace Their Pacifier

Blog Sleep

Gentle Strategies to Help Babies Self-Soothe During Night Wakings

Pacifiers are a wonderful tool for soothing and settling babies, offering comfort and security at sleep times. For newborns and younger babies, they can be a fantastic sleep aid—helping to calm fussiness, support naps on the go, and even provide some potential benefits for reflux and SIDS risk reduction.

As your baby grows, though, sleep cycles begin to mature. While they may have previously transitioned smoothly between cycles, from around 5 to 6 month —especially during the 6 month sleep regression—they may start to wake fully between each one. Naps may become shorter, and nights can suddenly feel very broken.

During this stage, a pacifier can still be incredibly useful, but you might find yourself getting up multiple times a night to pop it back in. It’s a quick fix in the moment, but understandably exhausting when it’s happening every couple of hours. This doesn’t mean the pacifier is a problem, it’s still a helpful sleep association, but it does mean your baby might need a little support in learning how to find and replace it on their own.

The good news? If your baby is around 6 to 7 months and is starting to reach and move independently, you can gently teach them how to replace their pacifier themselves. With a bit of daytime practice, many babies quickly build this skill, and with it, more settled nights for everyone.

Teaching Your Baby to Replace Their Own Pacifier

Step 1: Teach the Movement During Playtime
Babies learn best through repetition and play, so start by practicing while they’re awake. Hand your baby the pacifier and guide their hand to their mouth. If they aren’t already doing this themselves, encourage them to try the motion.
Once they get the hang of it, now always just place thepacifier in their hand and let them place it in their mouth. This helps build muscle memory and confidence, making it easier to do the same thing during the night.

Step 2: Encourage Them to Find It in the Crib
During naps or bedtime, place the pacifier close toy our baby’s hand rather than directly into their mouth. Over time, they’ll learn to reach out and find it.

You can make this easier by scattering a few pacifiers around the crib so there’s always one nearby. Glow-in-the-dark pacifiers are also a great option - they’re easier to spot in a dark room without stimulating your baby fully awake.

Step 3: Give Them Time to Try at Night
If your baby stirs during the night, try pausing before going in. If they’re moving around or lightly fussing, they might be looking for their pacifier. Giving them a moment to find it themselves (even if they don’t succeed right away) encourages that independence and to keep trying.

If needed, you can gently guide their hand toward it rather than doing it for them completely. Most babies will get the hang of this within a few nights with consistent encouragement.

What If My Baby Still Wakes Frequently?
Pacifiers can be an amazing tool for helping babies feel safe, soothed, and settled at sleep time. And once they’ve learned how to replace it on their own, you’ll often see a big improvement in how they resettle during the night.

But if your baby is still waking often, even though they can confidently replace the pacifier themselves, it’s worth looking at what else might be going on. Sometimes frequent night waking is a sign that another piece of the sleep puzzle needs adjusting.

The best approach to building independent sleep skills is a holistic one. This means looking at everything from wake windows and sleep environment to day naps and bedtime routines. If you’re unsure where to start, a gentle sleep training guide can help you navigate this stage with confidence. It offers step-by-step support that is
realistic, flexible, and respectful of your baby’s needs.

We hope the tips shared here have provided valuable insights and strategies to help guide you on your sleep journey with your little one. When it comes to your baby’s sleep, expert advice can make all the difference, and we’re thrilled to share the knowledge of one such expert.
The following information was generously provided by Melissa Gilchrist, whose experience and expertise in infant and toddler sleep have helped families around the world.

About Melissa Gilchrist: Melissa Gilchrist is a Certified Infant and Toddler Sleep Consultant and the founder of Baby Sleep Code, an evidence-based sleep brand that has helped over 10,000 families worldwide. Combining the latest in infant sleep science with a holistic, supportive approach, Melissa’s guides are designed to take the guesswork out of sleep and empower parents with the knowledge and confidence to navigate sleep from the newborn stage and beyond.